RestaurantWashington HeightsAudubon / W 165th St
Niccolo Pizzeria
A small, friendly slice shop with thin crispy crust; it's new and has little press, so treat it as promising.
2127 Amsterdam AveAmsterdam Ave near W 166th St
What it is
Niccolo Pizzeria is a small pizza and gelato shop at 2127 Amsterdam Ave, next door to Native Noodles. Its website describes a concept built around organic Italian flour, San Marzano tomatoes and olive oil sourced by owner Cleber, and lists pizza, focaccia, gelato, bomboloni and tiramisu.
Who it’s for
People who want a quick slice, a small sit-down lunch, or a soft-serve gelato in the Audubon area.
Standout details
A May 2026 post by a visiting food blogger says the shop opened about a year and a half earlier, that its cheese slices had a very thin, crispy crust, and that Cleber explained the menu, offered gelato samples and recommended his house Calabrian chili oil. City inspection records show an inspection on June 15, 2026.
Honest verdict
A friendly, small, and young business with a clear point of view. Independent coverage is limited to personal reviews, and hours disagree across listings, so I have omitted them; call (646) 964-5061 before you go.